I am running an 8:1 at the moment because when I changed the piston that's all they had in standard size.
I have been running a larger main jet for quite a while as when the piston failed last time I had been running hard 2 up. My thoughts at the time were that a combination of weak mixture,slipped ignition timing and a lower than normal gear ratio caused my first catastrophic piston failure.
When I rebuilt the engine I fitted a new big end, Carrillo rod,piston muff and liner. Since then I have upped the gear ratio to standard,it doesn't go as well now though, and fairly carefully run the engine in.
So I was suprised to find that the barrell was as scored as it is.The compression was ok but not like my original Comet where you could stand on the kickstart without it going over compression. My 1932 Sunbeam will not go over compression without the valve lifter, by comparison you could kickstart the Comet without the lifter which was why in the end I stripped it down.It would still cruise at 65-70 without much fuss, it just goes to show how relatively bullet proof a Comet engine is..john