I would always retime if swapping out the ATD. Not a big job, and you won't have to worry about movement when the old is removed. With the ears of the ATD wearing, it may affect the retard position of the new unit. What is the reason for exchanging? if the springs are worn new ones can be placed with just removing ATD cover. The fibre gear seem to last for miles, but have heard they seperate in time. I have blamed the ATD for many a bad thing, only to find it was my poor carburator adjusting, dying magneto condenser, bad fuel, burning exhaust valve, etc. The only thing I notice is a bit of run up when idling at the stoplight. I tried one of the electronic mags, but have gone back to the original unit, no problems this month. Good Luck with the tune up. Cheers, Dan